A glance from the side never lied
This profile view of Beyonce’s face shows how her nose looks thinner now. This before and after picture shows her in 1998 and 2011.
The difference from 1998 to 2013 is very obvious. Here’s the thing: the lighting at that Super Bowl show was just awful. While her nose still looked different than it did 10 years prior, it looked way better in the pre-game interviews. I’m sure her PR staff went crazy after those pictures were released. They were probably saying, “Who signed off on that lighting?!?!”